Replacing Dryvit Siding with James Hardie: A Lancaster County Homeowner’s Experience

For many homeowners in Lancaster County, Dryvit siding wasn’t a choice—they inherited it when they purchased their homes, unaware of the hidden problems that could follow. What seemed like a sleek, low-maintenance exterior often turns out to be a costly burden, with moisture intrusion, structural damage, and resale concerns becoming all too common. One local homeowner learned this firsthand after spending tens of thousands of dollars trying to fix recurring Dryvit issues—until he turned to Glick’s Exteriors for a permanent solution.

What Is Dryvit and Why Is It a Problem?

Dryvit is a type of Exterior Insulation and Finish System (EIFS)—commonly referred to as synthetic stucco. It became popular in the 1980s and 1990s for its insulation properties and smooth appearance. Unfortunately, many homes with Dryvit siding have experienced serious moisture intrusion issues, especially in the variable weather conditions of Southeastern Pennsylvania.

Unlike traditional stucco, Dryvit doesn’t allow moisture to escape once it gets behind the surface. Over time, this leads to hidden mold, rot, and structural damage—not to mention costly repairs and lower home resale value.

A $70,000 Lesson in Siding

Lancaster County homeowner, Bill Stratton, bought his home in 2003. Since then, he spent over $45,000 on Dryvit remediation. When new issues arose that were projected to cost an additional $25,000, he knew it was time for a change.

“I started questioning spending good money on a bad investment in our siding,” Bill said.

That’s when Bill contacted Glick’s Exteriors—a trusted local expert in siding replacement and Dryvit remediation.

Before photo showing cracked Dryvit siding in Lancaster County, PA

Partnering with Glick’s Exteriors

From the first conversation, Bill knew his family was in good hands.

“It was outstanding,” Bill shared. “From the support we received from Ryan Zimmerman, including all of the extra work he did to help us secure approval from our HOA, to all of the communication and execution from Chris Glick and his team –  they were great to work with and cleaned up the site beautifully upon completion of the work.”

Glick’s guided the homeowner through every step of the process—from navigating HOA requirements to the final cleanup. The team’s responsiveness and professionalism stood out, making what could have been a stressful project feel seamless.

The Solution: Hardie Siding in Navajo Beige

To replace the deteriorating Dryvit, Glick’s installed James Hardie 8 1/4 Cedarmill and Board & Batten siding in the elegant color Navajo Beige. The transformation was stunning—not just visually, but structurally and financially.

Hardie siding is one of the most durable and low-maintenance siding materials available. Unlike Dryvit, it’s resistant to moisture, won’t trap water behind the surface, and stands up to Pennsylvania’s changing seasons.

“Our neighbors, to this day, continue to compliment how nice our home looks since our Glick’s Exteriors residing project,” the homeowner said. “And I no longer need to worry about down the road selling a Dryvit home…that issue for us has gone away forever.”

After photo showing James Hardie Navajo Beige siding installed by Glick’s Exteriors

Why James Hardie Is a Smart Upgrade in PA

James Hardie siding is engineered for the climate, which makes it a great fit for homes in Lancaster County and the surrounding areas. It’s:

• Moisture-resistant
• Fade- and pest-resistant
• Highly customizable with design styles and colors
• Backed by long-term warranties

When paired with expert installation by a team like Glick’s Exteriors, it provides peace of mind and long-lasting curb appeal.

Warning Signs You May Have a Dryvit Problem

Many homeowners don’t realize there’s an issue until it’s too late. If your home has Dryvit siding, watch for:

• Cracks or bulges in the finish
• Water stains near windows or doors
• Spongy or soft areas behind the surface
• High humidity or mold in your interior walls

Even if you haven’t had issues yet, you could be facing hidden damage that will be expensive to uncover and repair.

The Glick’s Difference

Glick’s Exteriors has been serving southeastern Pennsylvania since 2010 with honesty, craftsmanship, and integrity. Their reputation is built on:

• Clear communication
• Clean worksites
• Fair pricing
• High-quality materials
• Long-lasting results

Whether you’re dealing with Dryvit, old stucco, or any other exterior issue, the Glick’s team offers guidance you can trust.

Final Thoughts from the Homeowner

“We’ve gone from a problem-prone siding on our house to one of the nicest sidings in our neighborhood.”

That’s the kind of transformation Glick’s delivers—not just better materials, but peace of mind and pride in your home.

Is It Time to Replace Your Dryvit?

If you live in Lancaster County or nearby areas and are concerned about your home’s siding, don’t wait for more problems to appear. Contact Glick’s Exteriors for a free consultation and find out how the team can help you transition from Dryvit to a beautiful, long-lasting solution like James Hardie siding.

Schedule your inspection today.